Hypothesis
The neutrophils that flood the airways in severe RSV infection would contribute to controlling the virus, to lung inflammation, or to how sick the host becomes.
What failed
In RSV-infected mice, antibody depletion of neutrophils did not substantially change type I interferons, IL-6, TNF-alpha or IL-1beta, nor viral load. Neither depleting neutrophils nor boosting them with CXCL1 changed peak disease severity measured by weight loss.
Broken assumption
Abundant airway neutrophils in severe RSV are a driver of disease rather than a bystander.
Why
The authors conclude that in this mouse model lung neutrophils neither help antiviral defence nor drive disease; their abundance in severe infant disease is not explained.
From the published paper: Kirsebom et al. Scientific Reports, 2020. ↗CC BY